Feather and Down Pillows: What You Don’t Know About America’s Favorites

Feather and Down Pillows

“This down pillow has ripped open and it’s so funny! My step-father, Steve, will clean up the mess when he gets home.”

Some people swear that feather and down pillows are the only way to sleep. I myself have slept on down pillows for most of my life. There’s a lot to like. They’re durable, moldable, and work reasonably well for all sleep positions. I knew that alternatives existed, but the only ones that seemed much different than my comfortable and familiar down pillow seemed gimmicky or even potentially hazardous.

Unfortunately feather and down pillows come with a lot of baggage.

Cleaning: What a $%#ing Pain!

First, let’s talk about washing these things. I have personally ruined several down pillows and at least one comforter in the wash. I’m sure many of you have done the same. It’s quite easy to ruin things filled with feathers and down:

  • Drying it too hot can scorch the fill.
  • Allowing it to sit wet for too long will result in a really foul-smelling mold. Be sure not to forget them in the washer!
  • Washing and drying both can cause clumping of the down clusters, which will cause your pillow to become lumpy and flat.

Proper cleaning of down and feather pillows will help them last longer, but it is very easy to destroy them in the process.

Allergic Reactions to Feather and Down

Down is often blamed for causing allergic reactions. It turns out that genuine feather allergies are quite rare. Most reactions can actually be attributed to dust mites or mold, both of which can thrive inside a down pillow. Down feathers tend to become more allergenic with age – they slowly become more and more contaminated. For this reason, some recommend that down pillows be replaced as often as every 6 months. That can get pricey in a hurry!

Feathers and Down Don’t Grow on Trees.

That’s right, you heard it here first… down comes from ducks and geese! While you might expect that there are humane ways of obtaining these feathers, in reality it’s pretty traumatic for the birds no matter how it’s done.

80% of the down and feathers used in products are produced in China. The production techniques are unfortunately pretty grim.

Duck Down

Would you tear out this poor mother’s feathers?

How are feathers removed from birds? There are three unpleasant methods:

  1. After slaughter for meat – This generally involves boiling the bird’s corpses in water for several minutes to loosen the feathers. The body feathers are then plucked and the down is separated either by hand or machine.
  2. Live plucking – Every six to seven weeks before slaughter, birds are captured and “harvested.” They are held down by the neck and their feathers torn out. This process often results in the bird’s skin being torn. Public outrage over this practice has resulted in large retailers like IKEA and Patagonia eliminating live-plucked down from their products.
  3. Gathering from live birds – This method involves brushing or combing the animals to extract feathers and down that are ready to fall out naturally. While this technique doesn’t sound too terrible, in reality, the birds are restrained in the same way employed during “live plucking” and are at best severely traumatized.

Those who are concerned with animals’ well-being, be aware that purchasing down products directly supports this industry and the poor treatment of animals.

Flat Pancake Pillow!

Light and fluffy is great if all you need is cuddly. However, when sleeping, your head and neck need proper support so that your muscles are relaxed and your spine is aligned in a straight line. It’s hard to get that support when your pillow turns into a pancake in the middle of the night. Down and feather pillows generally suffer from a lack of support. They tend to flatten out under the weight of your head during the night causing a downward bend in your neck. They require frequent refluffing and adjustment to maintain loft and support.

Feather and Down Pillows Retain Heat.

Feather and down fill types retain body heat, which can make your pillow hot and uncomfortable, particularly during the summer months. The fill can restrict free air flow preventing heat from escaping. Repeatedly having to flip to the cool side of your pillow is not conducive to good sleep. By the way, that mold I mentioned… It loves the savory conditions of your sweaty down pillow!

So What’s the Magical Alternative to Down and Feather Pillows?

I would have been stuck with my sad squishy down sack forever, but thanks to a friend’s recommendation, I tried a buckwheat pillow. I wasn’t an instant convert; it was very different, so it took some getting used to. But, after about a week, I was sleeping much better. I tossed out my down pillow. A year after that I was manufacturing my own buckwheat pillows. Yes – I love them that much! Don’t take my word for it. Our customer’s reviews speak for themselves! I love this testimonial from a feather pillow convert:

“As far back as I can remember using a pillow at night, I’ve used a feather pillow. Pillows stuffed with the softest down have been my default, my go to. I haughtily looked down on pillows of any other type. This was even though I’d been growing more dissatisfied with my feather pillow’s tendency to wake me in the middle of the night because it’s lofty support had degraded and squished away through after a few hours…

The first week was difficult. I was so used to the soft, plushness of feather pillows: the buckwheat pillow felt like a slab of concrete in comparison. But, then the second week hit. By then, my muscles were well adjusted. The pillow start to feel supportive rather than hard. I was a convert! This pillow is great. It excels at all-night-long support and good breathability. Unlike my feather pillows of the past, this pillow works with/for me, rather than against me. What a fantastic pillow!” –Geoff, verified Hullo customer


Looking for other alternatives to down and feather pillows? Check out our guide to types of pillows available.